by Andrew Evans
I was recently writing for another project about my struggle to wear a tallit gadol while seated, which is how I daven these days. Something about that posture really holds me back from feeling comfortable in my tallit.
This got me thinking about how much standing there is in Jewish life. Not necessarily how much standing is required, but how much standing is assumed. We stand for the Amidah, whose very name means standing. We rise when the ark is opened and when the Torah is carried through the congregation. We spend significant portions of the High Holidays on our feet. On Sukkot, we stand to shake the lulav and etrog.
Of course, Jewish tradition makes allowances for those of us who cannot stand. But there is a difference between being permitted to sit and having our rituals and religious spaces designed with the understanding that some of us will be sitting. Reading this week's Torah portion, Vayeitzei, I noticed something that I had never really paid attention to before. Jacob is lying down.
At the beginning of our parashah, Jacob has left Be'er Sheva and is traveling toward Haran. As the sun sets, he stops for the night, takes a stone from the place where he has stopped, places it near his head, and lies down to sleep.
The Torah tells us:
He had a dream; a stairway was set on the ground and its top reached to the sky, and messengers of God were going up and down on it. (Genesis 28:12)
This is one of the most recognizable images in the Torah. Jacob's ladder has inspired countless works of art, theological reflections, and understandings of the relationship between heaven and earth. It is an image of connection between the human and the divine, between the world in which we live and that which exists beyond our understanding.
And yet, for all the attention that we give to the ladder and to the angels ascending and descending upon it, I wonder how often we pay attention to Jacob's body. Jacob is not standing. He is not reaching toward heaven. He is not climbing the ladder. He is lying on the ground.
There is something particularly striking about this image for those of us whose bodies do not allow us to stand, or who spend much of our lives sitting or lying down. Here, in one of the Torah's most profound moments of divine revelation, the person encountering God is in a posture that we might otherwise associate with rest, illness, exhaustion, or even an inability to participate.
Jacob does not need to change his posture in order to encounter the divine. God meets him where he is.
I find myself wondering what it might mean to understand Jacob's ladder not as a means by which human beings ascend toward God, but as a means by which the divine becomes accessible to us.
So much of our religious language is about upward movement. We speak of spiritual elevation, of ascending to greater levels of holiness, of rising to meet the divine. We rise in the presence of sacred things. Our physical movements become expressions of our spiritual aspirations.
There is beauty in these metaphors and practices. But I also wonder what happens when we begin to associate physical movement too closely with spiritual movement. What happens when the language of spiritual aspiration is so consistently rooted in the abilities of particular kinds of bodies?
For those of us who cannot stand or climb, who cannot walk through our sanctuaries or rise from our seats without assistance, these metaphors can sometimes leave us wondering where we fit. Jacob's dream offers us another possibility.
The ladder reaches heaven, but Jacob remains on earth. The angels move between the two, but Jacob does not have to move at all. And it is there, with his body resting on the ground, that Jacob receives God's promise:
Remember, I am with you: I will protect you wherever you go and will bring you back to this land. I will not leave you until I have done what I have promised you. (Genesis 28:15)
God does not tell Jacob to climb the ladder. God does not ask Jacob to demonstrate his strength or his endurance. God does not require Jacob to stand in order to receive this promise. God simply promises to be with him.
When Jacob awakens, he declares, “Surely God is present in this place, and I did not know it!” (Genesis 28:16).
I wonder what it would mean for us to make this declaration about the places and postures that we so often overlook in our religious lives.
Surely God is present in this chair, and I did not know it.
Surely God is present in this wheelchair, and I did not know it.
Surely God is present in this bed, and I did not know it.
Surely God is present in this body, and I did not know it.
This is not to say that disability necessarily brings us closer to God, or that there is something inherently spiritually transformative about being unable to stand. Disabled people do not need to find spiritual meaning in our disabilities in order for our lives to be meaningful. Rather, I think Jacob's encounter invites us to reconsider the assumptions we make about what it looks like to be in the presence of God.
What would our Jewish communities look like if we took seriously the idea that holiness is equally accessible to us in all of our bodily postures? What if, instead of simply telling people that they may remain seated if they are unable to stand, we understood sitting as an equally meaningful way of participating in our collective prayer? What if we created rituals that emerged from the experiences of disabled bodies, rather than only adapting rituals that were created with nondisabled bodies in mind?
I am still figuring out how to comfortably wear my tallit while seated. I am still navigating what it means to inhabit Jewish ritual life in a body whose abilities have changed. And there are moments when I miss the physical expressions of prayer that were once available to me.
But this week, I am finding something comforting in the image of Jacob lying on the ground, dreaming of a ladder that reaches toward heaven.
Andrew Evans is a writer and educator whose work explores questions of meaning, community, and lived experience. Drawing on spiritual tradition, personal reflection, and social analysis, Andrew’s writing attends to the ways people make sense of their lives and responsibilities to one another.